12:59 AM
As we head into the All-Star break, let’s grade the Phils’ first half performance from top to bottom. You cannot complain about being 10 games over .500 and sitting atop the NL East by 4 games, but there is room for improvement everywhere. Obviously, that applies a lot more to some than others. The report card will be divided into 4 sections: bullpen, bench, starting rotation, and the lineup. We’ll take a look at the new reality TV stars to kick things off.
THE BULLPEN
After proving to be the league’s best bullpen and serving as a very critical component to the 2008 championship season, there was a lot of pressure on the pen for a repeat performance.
Gaining national exposure on a weekly basis from the MLB Network’s The Pen only added to the weight on shoulders of the relievers. As the season progressed, it became even more evident that the bullpen would need to stay sharp in order for the Phillies to have success in 2009. The starting rotation was struggling and an injury to Brett Myers only made matters worse. Poor outings by starters resulted in many early showers, which meant even more innings would be needed in relief.
After a rocky start due to being overworked, the bullpen has settled down significantly. Here is where they rank out of the 16 NL teams:
- 3.95 ERA – 11th
- 280.1 IP – tied for 5th
- 141 BB – 4th
- 241 SO – tied for 5th
- 23 Saves – 8th
- 32 HR Allowed – 2nd
And now for the individual members…
Ryan Madson (3-4, 3.02 ERA, 45 G, 44.2 IP, 16 BB, 44 SO)
Last year Ryan really solidified his role as the team’s 8th inning man and as one of premier setup men in the league. He started off the season by living up to his new reputation. When Brad Lidge went onto the disabled list, Madson was asked by Charlie Manuel to fill in as the club’s closer. He definitely had the stuff, but he appeared to lack the mentality. Before Lidge went on the DL, Madson’s ERA sat at 2.22. After blowing 2 saves and picking up 3 losses during his tenure as the closer, his ERA ballooned to 3.46. He went from dominant to very hittable in the blink of an eye. Fortunately, Lidge has returned and Madson is back in a spot he has grown to become very comfortable. He was sharp leading into the break and appears to be back on track. Grade: B+
Chad Durbin (1-2, 4.47 ERA, 39 G, 44.1 IP, 28 BB, 43 SO)
After having a breakout year as a reliever, Chad Durbin has cooled off. Last year his ERA was 2.87 and he was definitely the unsung hero of the bullpen. While his ERA is up a lot more than you would like, he continues to do a lot for the Phillies. He has seen the bulk of his action in the 7th inning. As a former starter, he is still capable of going more than one inning if called upon. 7 of his outings have been over 2 innings long. Grade: B-
Clay Condrey (4-2, 3.71 ERA, 33 G, 34.0 IP, 14 BB, 22 SO)
Clay has surprised us all. He was supposed to be once again nothing more than the Phils ‘mop up’ guy. Well Charlie has certainly given Condrey a huge vote of confidence. 16 of his 33 appearances have been in games where the game is tied, within 1 run, or the opposing team had the tying run at least on deck. He was in 11 games of that nature all of last year. Clay had a few rough outings that lead to a DL stint on 6/22 with a strained oblique. Grade: B+
Brad Lidge (0-4, 7.03 ERA, 35 G, 18/24 SV, 32.0 IP, 19 BB, 37 SO)
Brad has by far been one of the Phillies’ biggest disappointments. You knew the save streak would not last forever, but you did not expect Lidge to blow 6 games before the break. It took 18 appearances for Lidge to finally surrender his first run of the 2008 season. In 2009 Lidge gave up 16 ER in his first 18 games. After blowing 2 saves at the new Yankee Stadium on 5/23-5/24 and another 2 in LA on 6/5-6/6, he was placed on the DL. Brad’s ERA is toast for the season, but he needs to forget about that. There are plenty of games to still be saved. Since coming back from the DL he has been perfect in save opportunities (5 for 5). Grade: C-
Jack Taschner (1-1, 5.20 ERA, 21 G, 27.2 IP, 20 BB, 17 SO)
You have to feel for Jack. When the season started you knew he wasn’t going to last too long. The initial thought was that he would lose his spot as soon as J.C. Romero returned, but he dodged that bullet. He still started to see less and less time, as he only pitched 5 games in all of June. Taschner never got a chance to pitch consistently and his numbers did not help his case. Of course, that works both ways. He was designated for an assigment on 7/3. Grade: D
Chan Ho Park (2-1, 3.16 ERA, 18 G, 25.2 IP, 9 BB, 29 SO)
Chan Ho Park is my first-half bullpen MVP. Now I know that is not the most prestigious award in baseball, but you have to look at what this guy has done. Chan Ho signed with the Phillies after he was promised a chance to compete for the #5 spot in the starting rotation. He deservedly won the spot after an outstanding spring training, but he quickly unraveled in the regular season. After being moved to the bullpen after his final start on 5/12, Park has been outstanding. He has become one of the more versatile guys in the pen. He can come into a tight game and get some crucial outs or eat up multiple innings. 6 of his 18 relief appearances have been over 2 innings. 3 of them have been 3 innings long. In those 6 multi-inning relief appearances, he has only given up 1 ER. Chan Ho has adjusted to his new role very quickly and has not looked back. You have to really admire that. Grade: A-
Scott Eyre (1-1, 2.16 ERA, 27 G, 16.2 IP, 10 BB, 12 SO)
Lou Piniella’s reluctance to use Scott Eyre in 2008 was one of the best things that has happen to the Phillies in awhile (besides winning a World Series maybe). Eyre pretty much fell into the lap of the Phils last season via a trade with the Cubs. This year he has been a very reliable member of the pen. He is probably the most efficiently used relief pitcher the Phils have to offer. Charlie has brought Eyre into a game 8 separate times to face one specific batter. After he got the out, he was plucked from the game. He did the same thing with 2 batters in 5 different games as well. Eyre has the best ERA on the pitching staff and does most of his work in the later innings. Eyre landed on the DL with a calf injury he suffered while running from the bullpen on 6/11 at Citi Field. He is back and looks close to becoming himself. He has only given up 4 ER all year and that all happen on 4/27. Grade: A
J.C. Romero (0-0, 3.14 ERA, 17 G, 14.1 ERA, 12 BB, 11 SO)
The announcement of Romero’s 50-game suspension was a huge bummer to this team. As one of the most passionate guys on the field and in the clubhouse, his presence was missed. Last year J.C. was the primary left-handed arm out of the bullpen. His 1st half numbers are from a relatively small sample size, but J.C. has not been as sharp as he has been in the past. His outings have been pretty rocky and he is letting too many men get on base. He has only faced the minimum amount of batters in 6 of his 17 appearances. You do not want to see that from one of your most vital relievers. Hopefully J.C. has shaken out the rust and will be ready to go in the second half. Grade: B
Tyler Walker (1-0, 1.64 ERA, 9 G, 11.0 IP, 1 BB, 5 SO)
Tyler Walker has made the most of his short time in the majors for the Phils this year. After making his Phillies debut on 6/16, Walker has been almost flawless. The only 2 runs he gave up occurred during the 11-1 blowout loss to the Braves on 7/1. Other than that, he has really gotten the job done. He is averaging only about 13.5 pitches in his 11 innings of work. Unfortunately, he will probably get the boot when Clay returns. Grade: N/A (Still has way too much to prove)
Lastly, Sergio Escalona gets an A for frequent flyer miles and Kyle Kendrick gets a ‘sad face’ for probably never seeing the major leagues as a Phillie ever again.
*Photo Courtesy of AP*